Heddon-on-the-Wall Local History Society
  • Home
  • Calendar
  • Introduction
  • Where are we?
  • History Map
  • Timeline
    • Prehistoric
    • AD43 to 1599
    • 1600 to 1799
    • 1800 to 1899
    • 1900 to 1999
    • 2000 to 2099
  • Heddon's History
    • Prehistory
    • Hadrian's Wall >
      • Vallum excavation (1893)
      • Hadrian's Wall excavation 1926
      • Wall ditch, Bays Leap (1958)
      • Hadrian’s Wall: Archaeological research by English Heritage 1976-2000
      • Throckley & Heddon entanglements
      • WallWatch
      • English Heritage (2020)
      • Wardell-Armstrong Archaeolgy Reports
      • Historic England Archives
    • Six townships >
      • 1 Heddon township >
        • Heddon in the Middle Ages
        • Common Land
        • Middle Marches
        • Tithe Award
        • St Andrew's Church >
          • Stained Glass Windows
          • Churchyard
          • Monuments of church & churchyard (1991)
          • Monuments Page 2
          • Vicars of Heddon
        • Village property
        • Heddon Hall >
          • Sale of Heddon Hall 2012
        • Heddon Banks Farm
        • Frenchman's Row
        • Methodist Church >
          • Heddon Methodist Church Centenary 1877-1977
        • Men's Institute
        • Women's Institute
        • Welfare Field
        • Knott Memorial Hall
        • Memorial Park
        • Schools
        • River Tyne
        • Coal Mining
        • Quarrying
        • Water Supplies
        • Transport
        • Waggonway & Railway
        • Occupations from 1800
        • Miscellaneous
      • 2 West Heddon township
      • 3 East Heddon township
      • 4 Houghton & Close House township >
        • Close House
      • 5 Eachwick township
      • 6 Whitchester township
    • Rudchester
  • People
    • Sir James Knott
    • Cadwallader J. Bates
    • Richard Burdon
    • Hugh Sinclair (Tim) Swann
    • George Clark
  • Old Photos
    • Postcards
    • Old photos 1
    • Old photos 2
    • Old photos 3
    • Old photos 4
    • Old photos 5
    • Old photos 6
    • Old Photos 7
  • Old News
    • Community News
    • Letter from the Emigrant Clergy of Frenchman's Row (1802)
    • Alleged Brutal Murder at Heddon-on-the-Wall (1876)
    • Sad boat accident at Ryton (1877)
    • Coronation tree (1902)
    • 65 Years on a Ferry Boat (1929)
    • Come claim your kiss at Heddon (1953)
    • The Swan (1972)
    • Heddon WI (1987)
    • Church House (1966)
    • Happy return (1993)
    • Hexham Courant (1997)
    • Butterfly Garden (1999)
    • Foot & Mouth (2001)
    • Remembrance Day (1996)
    • Remembrance Day (2016)
    • RAF at Ouston (2007)
    • Close House Golf Course (2009)
    • Heddon pupils celebrate British heritage (2011)
    • Roman Wall Forge (2011)
    • Diamond Jubilee (2012)
    • Auction of Bronze Statue, Close House (2012)
    • Heddon WI (2012)
    • Puffing Billy Festival (2013)
    • Heddon Village Show (2014)
    • View of the North (2014)
    • The Wall at Heddon (2014)
    • Heddon Village Show (2015)
    • War veterans singing send-off (September 2015)
    • Anglo-Saxon history (2014)
    • Heddon WI at 100 (2017)
    • Hadrian's Wall discovery (2019)
    • Tulip Mews (2020)
    • Mike Furlonger
    • Hadrian's Wall 1900 Festival
  • Memories
    • Olive White
    • Betty Cockburn
    • Betty Cockburn - miscellaneous information
    • Isabel Snowdon
    • William & Winnie Watson
    • Edith Ward
    • Mark Parker
    • Jack Lawson
    • Winnie Spoor
    • P Reay
    • Mr and Mrs Hall
    • Peter Chapman
    • Elizabeth Elenora Eames
    • Harry Murray
  • Other documents
    • Mackenzie (1825)
    • Bates (1886) >
      • Early & Roman
      • Townships
      • Heddon Church
      • Heddon & Houghton
      • Whitchester
      • Eachwick
      • West & East Heddon
      • Records
      • Addenda
      • Appendix A
    • History, Topography & Directory of Northumberland (Bulmer's) - 1886
    • History of Northumberland (1930)
    • Collingwood Bruce (1853)
    • Whellan (1855)
    • Post Office Directory (1879)
    • Prominent people in Heddon
    • Place names
    • Ad Murum
    • Archived documents
    • Thomas Bewick's History of British Birds (1826)
    • Census data 1801-1991
    • Historical Records 1888-1890
    • Knott Sale of Village Property (1924)
    • Extracts from Parish Council Records
    • Local colliery records
    • Blackburn (1938)
    • Clark (c.1963)
    • History of Church (1968)
    • Boundary Commission Report 1984
  • Walks
    • Walks 2
  • Blog
  • Contact us
  • Links
  • What's new
  • Site search
  • Past & Present
  • Photo of the Month
  • Place Name Studies
    • Meas & Meres
    • OS Name Books: Elsdon
    • OS Name Books: Allendale
    • OS Name Books: Cheviot Hills

The Stob Stanes, Yetholm Common and the Anglo-Scottish Border

14/10/2012

2 Comments

 
This year, I've spent a lot of time walking in the Cheviot Hills, exploring places I don't know or not been to for a long time. A recent walk on the England-Scotland Border east of  Kirk Yetholm led me to another mystery.

What started it was a visit to see the Stob Stones (or Stanes to the Scots).  Two large boulders, one standing, the other recumbent, east of the hillfort at Green Humbleton, and a stones throw (pun intended) from both the Pennine Way (high level route) and St Cuthbert's Way long distance footpaths. They are now firmly in Roxburghshire in Scotland, the Border boundary wall is to their east, but for a time were actually on the Border line.
Picture
The Stob Stones. Photo by A Curtis (2012).
Picture
The Stob Stones. Photo by A Curtis (2012).
They are often referred to as standing stones, which has a prehistoric connotation. What do the archaeologist think?

The Royal Commission on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Scotland. An inventory of the ancient and historical monuments of Roxburghshire  (1956)  records their visit to the stones in 1938. The record can be read on the excellent on-line resource known as Canmore.

However, they were not committing themselves to any opinion regarding their origin..
The "Stob Stones", two standing stones, are situated 230 yds W of the Border and over 1000ft OD. One still erect, measures 4 1/2ft wide at the base, narrowing to 3ft, by 1 1/2ft and 5 1/2ft high; there is evidence of stone packing at the base. The other now lies across its original bed 18ft to the S; it is 5ft long, 3ft wide and 2ft thick.

Both stones are of native porphyry and are locally called the "Gypsy Stobs" from the tradition that the kings of the Yetholm gypsies were crowned here.

Mack (J L Mack 1924) suggests that they are boundary marks, set up on the line of the Border; if this is correct they may be of early medieval date as this point is on the section of the Border that the English commissioners of 1222 regarded as fixed.
A later visit by the RCAHMS in 1978 revealed no further information. As well as the gypsy lore, the stones are still used as the destination for the annual ride out from Kirk Yetholm. They have always had importance locally. There is some information on the Yetholm gypsies here.
Picture
Standing stones west of White Hill. Photo by A Curtis (2012).
As I had walked that day from Hethpool in the Northumberland's College Valley, I was aware of the similarity between the Stob Stones and this site on White Hill. These stones are nowhere near the Border and the site has been interpreted as a likely Bronze Age burial mound.
If the large stones had originally been covered in a stone mound or cairn, then the stones must have been robbed for use elsewhere. The small stones packing the base are very similar to those around that of the erect Stob Stone.

My walking book informed me that the standing Stob Stone is aligned on the distant Eildon Hills. It is not easy to claim an alignment only of one stone as it depends where you are standing or whether an edge of the stone can be used for sighting. The stone  however, does have a 'nose' , which faces roughly in the right direction, as shown in the photo on the right.
Picture
Supposed 'alignment' of the Stob Stones with the Eildon Hills. Photo by A Curtis (2012).
I can't say I'm particularly convinced by this alignment. For one thing, why would it require two stones? My photo does though show something quite interesting. If you line up the stone with Eildon North Hill, the little nick on the ridge of Staerough Hill above Halterburn also lies on the alignment. As this is almost due west, It made me wonder where the sun might set at the solstice. However, that's not the purpose of my blog and I don't think I can use that to prove a prehistoric origin.
A correspondent, Geoff Holland, who knows these hills well, kindly provided me with a little more about the Canmore reference to J L Mack.

In 1924, James Logan Mack, an Edinburgh  lawyer and amateur historian, wrote a book entitled The Border Line from the Solway Firth to the North Sea, Along the Marches of Scotland and England. The edition most frequently found now is that published in 1926 by Oliver & Boyd (335pp,  119 illustrations by Donald Scott and others).

Mack's book remained the definitive account for many years. These Border lands have never been on the tourist trail. The broadcaster, Eric Robson produced a book called The Border Line in 2007, about his experiences following the same route, with much information about Mack and his writing.
Mack provides an illustration of the Stob Stones in Fig. 86, and on p. 267 tells us that

"... they were doubtless carried thither and erected to mark the boundary, in the early thirteenth century or even prior thereto".

Eric Robson, like me, thought them to be much older.

Mack goes on to discuss a linear earthwork of two, almost  parallel banks each with a ditch on the downhill side, which starts just north of the Stob Stones, and runs north-east to join the line of the current Border, south of Eccles Cairn and the stream valley known as Humbleton Swyre. This can still be seen today.
Picture
Fig. 87 - Old Border trench near the Stob Stanes. James Logan Mack (1924).
Picture
Old Border trench near the Stob Stones. A Curtis (2012).
As shown above, I had photographed the same feature on my first visit, from almost the same spot as Mr Mack, before I even knew of his work.

The cow in my photo is demonstrating one of the two ditches, as is the figure in his photo.The hill to the left is Burnt Humbleton (which carries the remains of a hillfort); in the background is Coldsmouth Hill, firmly in Northumberland, now rising above a forest plantation. The current Border runs along the base of this plantation, below Eccles Cairn, visible on the right..It  is demarcated by a proper wall and fence through which the St Cuthbert's Way footpath now passes via a gate. The linear embankment crosses the head of HUmbleton Sike. Much of its course is clearly visible in aerial view.
The linear earthworks on Stob Rig are described by the Canmore database here Link They say that two interrupted banks run nearly parallel for 300m along the hillside and that they are similar in situation and appearance to many others in the Cheviot area. Many of these so-called 'cross-dykes', often run across ridges and are associated with the old cross-Border tracks. They may have been built to control or constrain traffic although it is not known at what period they were constructed. This could be another interpretation here.

Mack (p267) however, identifies the linear embankment on Stob Rig with 'a dytche called the marche dyke' which existed in a survey in 1541-42. He describes a system of double dykes, leaving a strip of neutral territory between. This method was used, for example, at Scot's Dyke (part of the Western Marches), on parts of the former Border line north of Chew Green, and seems a reasonable explanation. The OS of 1:10,560 scale in 1863 shows this part of the Border line following a 'Track of Embankment' in a direction NNE-SSW, marked occasionally by 'piles of sods'. There is a change of direction away from this alignment north of the Stob Stones (a short section marked as undefined', then another at the Stones themselves.

A reasonable interpretation is that the ditches were cut to mark the Border line but the Stob Stanes were convenient markers already in situ, and of historic import. Interestingly, there is another linear embankment where the earlier Border line rejoined the current line at the col between White Law and Stob Rig.

John Barber (1999) considers the parallel earthworks acting solely as cross-routeway control, in this case controlling the two routes running from Kirk Yetholm to the Border that diverge just below the Stob Stones. They may well predate fixing of the Border line in Medieval times but as exiting features in the landscape may well have been used as markers to define its course.

From the Stob Stones the Border line ran east, then south-east, on an undefined alignment incorporating Oxpool and Tuppies Grave among other (possibly pre-existing) features.

Among the many things I don't know, one is why the Border was eventually moved to its current line, east of this location, where it is shown on the OS Edition of 1899. At the same time, its former extension around Yetholm Common via Tuppie's Grave and Wideopen Head was also removed. Possibly it had something to do with a revision of County and Parish boundaries in the late 1800s.
Picture
Section from OS 6 inch of Roxburghshire survey 1859, published 1863).
Picture
Section from OS 6 inch of Roxburghshire (revised 1896, published 1899).
Picture
Combined maps
My problems with the Stob Stanes and the Border line are these.

Why make the effort of lugging two huge boulders up here to mark the Border? Wouldn't it make more sense to define the Border using features already there? Wouldn't one stone have been sufficient?

Why doesn't the linear earthwork align on the stones? Again it appears to me that an existing earthwork may have been used to define the line, although its origin might still have been to define the Border much earlier in history. In 1862, the Ordnance Survey shows a bend just north-west of the Stob Stones marked by a Pile of Sods. Similarly to the east of the stones, much of its line is 'undefined' but uses an occasional named feature along its route, along with many such turf piles.

If someone has any of the answers, or a definitive explanation,  please let me know.

As further illustration of the changes in the Border, I have roughly plotted the Border lines shown on the OS maps above onto a Google Map aerial view below. The lines are only approximate, and are an interpretation of the line taken by the Border. Several of the features plotted can not currently be identified on the ground.

View Yetholm Common in a larger map
Why did the line of the Border change in this area between 1862 and 1899, when the OS show it in its current location. I naively thought its line had been fixed much earlier. This is not just a parish or county boundary after all. The Border wall erected at that time now takes a very straight line along the edge of the watershed, and is now followed by the Pennine Way.

Yetholm Common ended up divided, and the new line ceded parts of the land to both England and Scotland, although a large part of the former Common ended up on the English side, perhaps as it always had been..

I'll discuss the divergence of the Border east of its current line, around Yetholm Common, in another blog soon.
Links

John Barber (1999) 'The Linear Earthworks of Southern Scotland'. Transactions of the Dumfriesshire and Galloway Natural History and Antiquarian Society, Ser. 3, Vol. 73, p. 63-164.

2 Comments
edward pegler
10/6/2020 06:55:06 pm

Dear Andy. Your argument about the age of the stones makes a lot of sense. You may have moved on from thinking about this post in the last few years. However, I beleive that the border, as viewed by the English at least, ran up the Halter Burn in the 16th century (and probably did even in the 12th century, judging by old charters from Kelso), going as far as just below White Law, where it did something strange and joined the present border to the south. You can find it in the Mack book that you mentioned. However, Yetholm Common, between this and the valley of Trowupburn, was claimed by Scots and English in the 17th century, and one of its eastern boundary points was the Stob Stanes. I can send you quite a good unpublished discussion of this on pdf if you want it. best wishes Ned

Reply
Andy Curtis
12/6/2020 02:36:01 pm

Hi Ned
Many thanks for the information you sent. It answers many of the questions regarding the Border Line in this area. I will reproduce the document on the sister article to this one:
Yetholm Common (24/06/2015). Search the blog using the categories: Yetholm OR Cheviot.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    RSS Feed

    Author

    Andy Curtis

    Archives

    November 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    October 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    March 2020
    November 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    March 2019
    January 2019
    November 2018
    October 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    January 2018
    October 2017
    September 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011


    Categories

    All
    Agricultural Engineering
    Archaeology
    Barrow
    Bays Leap
    Beamish Museum
    Beer
    Beer-mat
    Bewcastle
    Books
    Border Line
    Brewery
    Brown
    Cabinetmaker
    Charlton
    Cheviots
    Churches
    Civil War
    Clennell Street
    Close House
    Coal Mining
    Cullercoats
    Cumbria
    Eachwick
    Earl Grey
    Elswick
    Family History
    Fishing
    Fishwives
    Folkestone Warren
    Forth Banks
    Furniture
    Gardens
    General
    George Clark
    Gibson
    Goods Station
    Hadrian's Wall
    Harbours
    Heddon
    Heddon Hall
    Hexham
    Hidden Chains
    Houghton
    Howick Hall
    Hunting
    Iron Sign
    Isaac Jackson
    John Grundy
    John Smith
    Knott
    Landslide
    Lead Works
    Lemington
    Lindisfarne
    Maritime
    Meetings
    Military Road
    Mill
    Monument
    Newburn
    Newcastle
    Newcastle Assizes
    News
    North Lodge
    North Shields
    Northumberland
    Northumberland Records Office
    Old Middleton
    Oral History
    Ouseburn
    Outings
    Photography
    Place Names
    Place-names
    Ponteland
    Ports
    Prehistory
    Pubs
    Quarries
    Railways
    Redesdale
    River Tyne
    Rock Art
    Roman
    Sadler
    Sanderson
    Schools
    Seaton Delaval
    Ships
    Shot Tower
    Slave Trade
    Songs/Poems
    Spearman
    Stagecoach
    Stained Glass
    St. Andrews
    Stephenson
    Swann
    Tea Robbery
    Throckley
    Town Farm
    Transportation
    Trinity House
    Victorian Panorama
    Walbottle
    Walk
    Water Supply
    William Brown
    Williamson
    Woodhorn
    Ww1
    Ww2
    Wylam
    Yetholm

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.